July 1, 2024

 

To the Permanent Representatives of Member and Observer States of the United Nations Human Rights Council,

 

Excellencies,

 

We, the undersigned survivors and families of the victims of the August 2020 Beirut port explosion, and Lebanese and international organizations, are writing to urge you, during the current UN Human Rights Council session, to support a resolution – or at a minimum a joint statement – at the United Nations Human Rights Council’s 56th regular session calling for the establishment of an international, independent and impartial fact-finding mission into human rights violations related to the Beirut port explosion of August 4, 2020.

 

During the Human Rights Council’s 52nd session in March 2023, 38 States issued a joint statement condemning the pervasive obstruction and interference with Lebanon’s domestic investigation into the Beirut Port explosion. They called on Lebanon “to take all necessary measures to safeguard, in law and in practice, the full independence and impartiality of the Lebanese judiciary,” and to ensure that a “swift, independent, impartial, credible, and transparent investigation into the explosion” be carried out.

 

More than a year later, an investigation into the explosion remains stalled and continues to be “hampered by systemic obstruction, interference, intimidation, and a political impasse,” as noted in the March 2023 statement. Victims of the blast and their families have been left with no recourse for truth and justice, as Lebanese officials have repeatedly obstructed the course of the domestic investigation.

 

For years, Lebanese and international rights groups have documented political interference with the judiciary, in addition to flawed investigations of politically sensitive murders, and criticized the lack of an independent judiciary, which has allowed a culture of impunity to flourish in Lebanon. Lebanese authorities have failed to take any significant steps since March 2023 to enable the domestic investigation to resume without undue interference and to uphold the rights of victims to an effective remedy, truth and justice.

 

Moreover, Lebanese authorities have yet to adopt a draft law on the independence of the judiciary that is in line with international standards or adopt necessary legal amendments that may allow the domestic investigation to proceed. In March 2023, nine members of Lebanon’s parliament introduced two draft laws that would strengthen the independence of judicial investigations and prevent political interference with the judiciary, but parliament has yet to vote on these laws.

 

In light of this deliberate inaction of the Lebanese authorities, an international, independent, and impartial fact-finding mission into human rights violations related to the Beirut port explosion is urgently needed.

 

In August 2022, six UN experts voiced their support for such an international investigation. In September 2023, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk denounced the lack of accountability for the Beirut port explosion and the repeated interference by Lebanese officials into the domestic investigation. He clearly stated that “it may therefore be time to consider an international fact-finding mission to look into human rights violations related to the tragedy.”

 

In March 2023, the UN expert on judicial independence warned that the interference into the domestic investigation impacted “the very ability of the Lebanese justice system to ensure accountability.” And on the three-year anniversary of the Beirut blast, in August 2023, more than 300 organizations and individuals called for the creation of an international fact-finding mission into the blast.

 

We jointly call on you to heed the calls of the victims of the Beirut blast, their families, Lebanese and international rights groups, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, and the UN experts in order to build support for a resolution that establishes such an international fact-finding mechanism and bring this resolution forward at the Human Rights Council’s current 56^th session.

 

The findings of an international, independent investigation, conducted in accordance with the highest international standards and practices, could support a Lebanese domestic investigation if one is allowed to proceed, as well as any efforts in Lebanon and in third countries where individuals have filed criminal and civil cases to hold those responsible to account. Additionally, the investigative mechanism would provide recommendations to Lebanon and the international community on necessary steps to address the identified violations and prevent their recurrence.

 

We thank you for your attention to this important issue and stand ready to provide your delegation with further information.

 

Sincerely,

 

Lebanese and International Organizations

1. Alternative Press Syndicate
2. Amnesty International
3. Arab NGO Network for Development
4. Cedar Centre for Legal Studies (CCLS)
5. Gulf Centre for Human Rights (GCHR)
6. Helem
7. Human Rights Research League
8. Human Rights Watch
9. Kulluna Irada
10. The Legal Agenda
11. Lokman Slim Foundation
12. Samir Kassir Foundation
13. UMAM Documentation & Research
14. MENA Rights Group
15. The August 4 Collective
16. The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy (TIMEP)

 

Families of the Victims of the Blast

1. Arlette Hajj Abdou
2. Layale Abdallah
3. Degaule Abourjeili
4. Tania Daou Alam
5. George Bazergy
6. Elie Brax
7. Sarah Copland
8. Maroun Dagher
9. Wissam Diab
10. Cedric El-Adm
11. Cyril El-Adm
12. Dalal El-Adm
13. Nazih El-Adm
14. Eliane jean El-Hajj
15. Laura Jamil El-Khoury
16. Leila metri El-khoury
17. Nawal El-Murr
18. Pierre Gemayel
19. Joseph Ghafary
20. Nabil Hajj
21. Lara Hayek
22. Najwa Hayek
23. Lara Hojaiban
24. Noha Hojayban
25. Youmna Hojayban
26. Zita Hojayban
27. Dolly Kanaan
28. Yvonne Kfouri
29. Mireille Bazergy Khoury
30. Bassam Khoury
31. Elham Maacaron
32. Marie Makhlouf
33. Abdo Matta
34. Paul Naggear
35. Tracy Naggear
36. Gilberte Rahhal
37. Cecile Roukoz
38. Arze Salloum
39. Therese Salloum
40. Michel Sayegh
41. Carmen Khoury Sayegh
42. Lara Sayegh
43. Sarah Sayegh
44. Ajwad Shayya
45. Georges Zaarour

 

Families of the following firefighters 

1. Joe Bou Saab
2. Sahar Fares
3. Misal Hawwa
4. Charbel Hitti
5. Najib Hitti
6. Ramy Kaaky
7. Charbel Karam
8. Eli Khouzamy
9. Ralph Mellehy
10. Joe Noun